Skip to main content

Gertrude Stein Hated This Painting. And Yet...

A painting by Picasso from 1905 has just sold at auction for one hundred and fifteen million dollars -- what ArtNews calls "a rare nine figure purchase." The painting, from Picasso's so-called Rose period, is "Girl with Basket of Flowers":

I am in the camp that thinks the reasons why Picasso's Rose period work sells for more than his Cubist work are precisely the reasons why I don't like the paintings that much. That is, they are anachronistic pastiches of late nineteenth century Symbolist painting, their mythological content replaced instead with sentimental idealisations of family pastoral. However, there's no questioning the skill and sensitivity of Picasso's brushwork, particularly in the face of this girl.

The first owners of the painting were Gertrude and Leo Stein, the rich Americans who moved to Paris in the early 1900s and set themselves up as patrons to the avant garde (though their taste didn't extend to Picasso's Cubist work). Gertrude Stein held a long-running salon at her apartment on the Rue de Fleurus in Montparnasse, and in photographs from the time, you can see "Girl with a Basket of Flowers" hanging on the wall to the left of the stove:

Side note: each January I go to Paris with a group of American students, and on one of our "culture walks" we stop at the Rue de Fleurus building and talk about its history. Here is a photo I took of the front of the building. Stein's apartment was I believe on the ground or first floor. The salon space was a single storey building in the courtyard, which is visible through the iron gate in this photo:

Back to the painting. There is an interesting story about how the Steins purchased it. In 1905, Picasso was selling his paintings through a number of dealers, most of whom ripped him off and treated him quite badly. "Girl with a Basket of Flowers" was hanging in the establishment of Clovis Sagot, who was more of an antiques dealer than a gallerist. A few days after buying a different Picasso painting, Leo took Gertrude back to Sagot to see "Girl...", but Gertrude hated the picture, writing about it later in the following manner (it's in the third person, from The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas, but Stein is referring to herself):
She found something rather appalling in the drawing of the legs and feet, something that repelled and shocked her. She and her brother almost quarreled about this picture. He wanted it and she did not want it in the house. Sagot gathering a little of the discussion said, but that is alright if you do not like the legs and feet it is very easy to guillotine her and only take the head. No that would not do, everybody agreed, and nothing was decided.
Nevertheless, a few days later, Leo bought the painting anyway for 150 francs. A lot less than $115 million, but --  and let this sink in for a second -- twice as much as Sagot had paid Picasso. In one of his letters, Leo talks about what happened when he told Gertrude:
That day I came home late to dinner, and Gertrude was already eating. When I told her I had bought the picture she threw down her knife and fork and said, 'Now you've spoiled my appetite. I hated that picture with feet like a monkey's.'
Of course, she must have warmed to the painting, as it stayed on the walls of her salon room for decades, and she resisted later offers to buy it. The reason Gertrude changed her mind is that she met Picasso soon after "Girl..." came into her possession, but even that part of the story is complicated, as discussed by John Richardson in Volume 1 of his biography of Picasso.

Leo had become friends with a journalist called Henri Pierre Roché (who wrote Jules et Jim). Roché was a fixer who knew everyone in the Paris art world as well as everyone in the American expat community, and he enjoyed making introductions and no doubt getting a little cut of the proceeds every now and then. Roché was a regular at the Montparnasse bar La Closerie des Lilas, which is not too far from the Steins' apartment on Rue de Fleurus. Here are a couple of photos I took there when I popped in for a drink last January:

Picasso would often walk all the way from his studio in Montmartre to La Closerie to hang out with his writer friends. Shortly after the Steins bought Picasso's paintings, Picasso met Roché at La Closerie and asked him to make an introduction. Again, Gertrude resisted, but ultimately she did meet Picasso, became entranced by him, and became one of his strongest allies and friends over the next fifteen years.

So, then, to the anonymous billionaire who bought this 1905 painting by Picasso, I say: I hope you enjoy your purchase, not just because it's a pretty picture, but for the cultural and artistic histories that weave around it like incense around an icon.


  1. This line, "cultural and artistic histories that weave around it like incense around an icon." Yes, you can write. And doesn't it make you wonder about that moment when they meet? Thanks for the moment of imagining.

  2. I’ve been your silent reader for quite some time and now I’m delighted to say that I’m inspired by your articles. You have shared very valuable information and knowledge that people should recognise. Thank you for sharing. I would love to see more News and updates from you.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How to etch a linoleum block

Linoleum as a material for printmaking has been used for nearly a hundred years now. Normally, you cut an image out using special gouges similar to woodcut tools, cutting away the lino around the image you want to print. This is called relief printmaking, because if you look at the block from the side, the material that remains stands up in relief from the backing material. You then roll ink with a brayer over the surface of the block, place paper over it, and either print by hand or run it through a press. You can do complex things this way (for example, reduction linocuts), but the beauty of the process is that it is quick, simple, and direct.

A few years ago, I saw some prints that were classified as coming from etched linoleum blocks, and I loved the textures I saw in them. In the last few months, I've been trying to use this technique in my own studio, learning about it as one does these days from websites and YouTube videos. I've also had email exchanges with several pr…

A List of Every Drink in Hemingway's "The Sun Also Rises"

I first read Ernest Hemingway's 1926 novel "The Sun Also Rises" when I was a teenager, and immediately fell in love with it. For the last couple of years, I have had the incredible privilege of teaching a class based around Hemingway in Paris -- while living and teaching in Paris itself, close to the Boulevard du Montparnasse, where most of the action of the novel's first half takes place.

Of the many things that one notices about the book, the colossal amount of drinking is something that stands out. These people didn't just drink like fish: they drank like whales, as if the ocean they swam in was alcohol and they had set themselves the task of drinking the seas of the world dry of it. During my read-through of the book before class started last year, I tried to underline every mention of drink in the book. And now, purely in the interests of science, I am listing the entire menu of booze mentioned directly by name. Some preliminary observations:
Most of this is…

Brancusi in Plastic

Artist Mary Ellen Croteau is showing these columns made from recycled plastic cartons and lids in the window of the Columbia College bookstore on Michigan Avenue. They are a playful homage to Brancusi's "Endless Columns", with a serious environmental message for our times:

Mary Ellen also runs a wonderful experimental art gallery in a window space in west Chicago, called Art on Armitage. I will be exhibiting a mixed media piece there during August 2012.